It’s the Economy, Stupid

December 17, 2020 at 7:27 pm (Uncategorized) (, )

One of my favorite writers about all things Covid-related, Zeynep Tufekci, has an article on Substack that stopped me in my tracks.

It’s about the order in which Americans will likely be vaccinated.  Once again, it looks like we will as a nation do things very differently than the rest of the world.  Because we’re likely to have limited vaccines for many more months, we must make difficult choices.  It’s too bad we’re in this situation caused by yet another unforced error—this one by making our vaccine scarcity worse than it had to be. But that’s another post in itself.

We are first vaccinating health care workers and nursing home residents and workers.  This is completely logical and I think every country is doing the same.  What happens next is where things get tricky. As Tufekci argues quite convincingly in her latest piece, age and underlying health conditions account for an overwhelmingly percentage of Covid deaths.  90 percent of Covid deaths in the US are from people aged 55 and over.  If the US were interested in saving the most lives, it would be a no-brainer to next vaccinate the elderly living outside of nursing homes and those like me with risk factors.  But it looks like this is not going to be the CDC’s recommendation.  Instead, the vaccine will likely be offered next to essential workers (an ill-defined and potentially huge portion of the country.)  There is some logic to this, if our country’s goal is to limit the spread of Covid and thus get life back to normal more quickly.  Vaccinating workers could help our stuttering economy.  The CDC has also noted that prioritizing essential workers would address inequalities since many are people of color.  

Obviously, I’ve got (white) skin in this game.  I’ve been told by every healthcare professional I’ve talked to since March not to get Covid because I probably wouldn’t fare too well if I did.  This is why I am living apart from my family.  I’d like to return to my home.  I also don’t want to die. I feel very alone and anxious. Last night I slept for just a couple of hours.

I am angry at how the US has handled nearly every aspect of this pandemic since the beginning.  I feel strongly that this country has chosen economic well-being and the stock market over the lives of its citizens.  I’ve read and heard elected officials and policy makers at all levels argue that economic health trumps physical health.  Some have said outright that the elderly should sacrifice themselves for the good of the economy. Twitter trolls have told me to stop complaining because “I’m just going to die anyway.”  This expected new decision on how to vaccinate Americans feels to me like yet another prioritization of the economy over human life and health.  Certainly vaccinated essential workers can keep stores open, poultry processed, and packages delivered. But even the CDC panel making this recommendation is explicit that more lives will be lost with this choice.  I understand that this is terribly complicated. I know that economic hardship is awful, that the ranks of those in poverty grow every day, and that too many small businesses have shut down.  I know that people are hungry and food banks are struggling to meet the demand.  I know that kids who are out of school aren’t learning.  I know that mental health issues are on the rise.  From my perspective, though, you can re-open a business; you can’t bring back a dead person.  We could choose to pump more money into our economy.  Billionaires have gotten even wealthier during the pandemic.  We make choices not to tax those billionaires and instead let families go hungry.  There is one choice we can’t ever undo, though.  And that is to raise the multitude of the dead.  Many have died without family or friends with them.  If they were lucky, a masked and goggled nurse held their hand at the end.  The current prediction is that 500,000 Americans will die of Covid by March, 2021.

Prioritizing essential workers over the elderly and the at-risk will kill even more.  It’s hard for me to imagine that we would make this choice.  As Tufekci wrote today, “[I]n Utah, a 30-year-old teacher may be vaccinated long before someone over 70 or even 80—even though the latter are at so much greater risk if infected. In fact, it looks like teachers, police and food and agriculture workers will all precede adults over 65 and people with high-risk medical conditions.”

Once again, the US is charting its own course with Covid.  You can add this vaccination protocol to our rabid anti-masking sentiments and lackluster public policy for what separates the US from countries that have managed Covid much more successfully (Vietnam, Taiwan, New Zealand, Norway, Denmark, Canada, etc.) Tufekci points out that prioritizing essential workers is  “not what other countries rolling out the same vaccine are doing. For comparison…the UK-wide vaccination prioritization…sensibly ranks by risk, which corresponds to age.”

In theory every state is free to establish its own vaccination priorities.  But states have always used CDC guidelines in the past. 

I know this probably isn’t what any of you want to read.  It’s noteworthy that hardly anyone besides Tufekci is writing about this.  (She has been eerily prescient about almost everything Covid-related, from the CDC’s early nonsense policy against masking to restaurants and bars being the most significant vectors for transmission.) The pandemic was so 2020, and 2020 is almost over, right?  We have hopeful headlines about nurses getting vaccinated, with photos showing their relief.  Having the vaccine promised to us—“soon”— is supposed to soothe our Covid-fatigued souls.  It’s time to get our holly jolly on and go shopping!  Play some Christmas music, and do your civic duty by buying stuff (preferably with a mask on, but don’t get too strident about that or you’ll be accused of hating freedom.) If we crank the holiday music loudly enough, we can drown out snarks like me who are pointing out that we are woefully short of vaccines for the near and mid-term.  We can focus on 2021 like it’s some magical line fairies have drawn in the sands of time.  Coronavirus cannot cross that line.  Right? 

But here’s the thing.  I’m hurting.  I’m lonely.  I’m scared.  I’m confused why my country seems to value retail more than my life, my parents’ lives, and so many other lives.  And I don’t understand why this doesn’t feel important enough for people to talk about and worry over as a national community.  Don’t we all have someone like me—a grandparent, a friend with cancer, a cousin with diabetes?  Someone who has been following the rules and hunkering down because she believes her life has meaning.  I can’t live under a rock forever because my country doesn’t want to see me.  But I’m here, marking time until the rest of the country cares enough to put on a mask, stay out of restaurants, not have a Christmas party…and give me a vaccine. 

6 Comments

  1. Norane Freistadt said,

    Well stated Rebecca! In our extremely capitalistic nation, we value economy over health, but I can only hope with new federal leadership, we will see some slow change. Not timely enough for vaccines though.

    • Rebecca Stanfel said,

      Yes, I hope we can chart a new course in 2021. I am ready to come out from under my rock! Thanks for reading 💜

  2. mmsw922 said,

    Without in any way minimizing the fear and loneliness and pain and utterly righteous indignation you’re feeling, Rebecca, I feel as if your writing–now and through the year–represent anything but marking time. You’re willingness to wrestle with Covid and politics and our attitudes all intertwined stands as its own great contribution.

    • Rebecca Stanfel said,

      Wow, thanks Miriam! That means a lot to me. I had the great joy of getting to spend 5 days at home with no restrictions last week. Andrew was potentially exposed to Covid, and so the separate quarantines we did to be careful before the (thankfully) negative results came back,
      along with Andrew’s fairly tangential connection to the kid who had been exposed (both he and Andrew were wearing masks during the time in question) all combined for my doctor to OK me spending time at home with no masks, filters, or distancing. It was so amazing. Just getting to experience daily life with Jay and Andrew was the best. I had no idea how much and how viscerally Is been missing hugs from them. But Andrew went back to his twice a week school, and me to my separate place. It’s harder now that I had a taste of home life again. I know this makes sense, but I am wrestling with my apart-ness (not just from my family but from society) and a lot of anger that at every step, people keep making bad decisions that are going to kill more people. My rage at the debacle with the administration passing on acquiring additional doses of the Pfizer vaccine and the prospect of watching everyone jockey and lobby to be an “essential worker” (I just know that grocery store clerks are going to less
      essential than Wall Street brokers) isn’t really accomplishing anything accept make me grumpy enough to write something. So, thank you.

  3. Dorothy said,

    I am looking at 2020/2021 as a bell curve and we are peaking at the top come the change in year. In our crazy Oregon County our locals have been openly bucking the governor’s orders, even bringing nutty ordinances to court that said the outbreak isn’t bad — this was less than a month ago. Now our little county is having 5 deaths a day and they redeploying county employees to do contact tracing. Probably are not getting many applicants for the job since they downplayed it all along.

    I have confidence that it will get better. Who know when we will get a vaccine in our arms… but personally I don’t want to be one of the last to die when the end is within 6-10 months (hopefully). I’ve also resigned myself to wearing a mask for the rest of my life…. which I hope is long.

    Thanks for writing!

    • Rebecca Stanfel said,

      And thanks for reading! The insanity level here is also off the charts. Our legislature, which meets every other year, is coming to town in January. In a straight party line, all the Republicans voted not to require masks indoors and to compel in person sessions. So Helena is good and screwed until March, when these yahoos go home. It will get better and I mostly know that. But living apart chafes at me and I want someone in a position of authority to make a good Covid decision. I know that will come to. Take good care

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: